Old Hall Barn

59 Customer Reviews

• "Ideal for a short stay and exploring the Hope Valley."

  Old Hall Barn is small but has everything you need. Perfect when good value is sought rather than luxury. The welcome folder emphasised what not to do rather than how to enjoy.

  Reviewed by Ian4.4★Jun 2025

• "Really lovely cosy cottage."

  Ground floor bedroom and bathroom ideal. The woodburner was a bonus and the central heating kept the cottage lovely and warm over Christmas. The central location worked well for us and no noise from the pub car park. We had our own private parking.

  Reviewed by Sheila4.7★Dec 2024

• "A very comfortable and warm cottage with everything you needed for a week."

  The location was great for a car free holiday with easy access to both train and bus. The village was lovely with a range of cafes and a very good pub. There was a range of excellent walks right from the doorstep and Old Barn cottage was a welcome base to return to after a long days walk.

  Reviewed by Sarah4.7★Nov 2024

• "Very warm comfortable barn conversion."

  Log burning stove but logs not supplied.Excellent location for station ,walks,and bus . Fantastic food at Old hall Inn next door and Curry cabin and Spar Shop 5mins away with excellent choice of Cooks Meals.

  Reviewed by anne4.7★Oct 2024

• "Very comfortable and cosy accomodation."

  Well equipped.Train station and bus stop very close.All together had a very good holiday despite the weather.

  Reviewed by Caroline4.4★Sep 2024

• "A beautiful property in a perfect location to discover the Peak District."

  I would highly recommend.

  Reviewed by Hilary5.0★Jul 2024

• "We loved our stay at the Old hall barn!"

  The owners were very accommodating and we loved the little touches such as the local cake! The barn was fantastic value for the size and space and was in a brilliant location! Nextdoor to a pub and tea rooms (we were not disturbed by any noise!) a short walk from the train station and on the doorstep of so many fantastic walks! Highly recommend! The only feedback we would have is maybe a refresh of the duvet cover which felt a little bit worn.

  Reviewed by Alice4.4★Apr 2024

• "Lovely property, perfect size for my partner and I."

  Cosy, clean and lots of character. We enjoied using the log burner and relaxing after our days out. The cottage is close to local amenities, without feeling like your sacrificing the desire to get away from it all. Its also a stones throw from beautiful places to visit. Easy parking and no hassle using the key safe and letting our selves in.

  Reviewed by James5.0★Dec 2023

• "This was our 3rd visit to the cottage, it is still as lovely as the first visit, only a couple of details the oven is in need of a clean and the boiler was temperamental sometimes had hot water sometimes didn’t."

  Reviewed by Sally4.4★Nov 2023

• "Generally lovely, please note the washing machine doesn’t work - It spins, but doesn’t release water."

  We needed to do some washing with an 18 month old, but we’re unable to.

  Reviewed by Len3.4★Nov 2023

• "This was my second stay at Old Hall Barn and was not disappointed."

  I had one slight issue and this was quickly dealt with once I contacted the owners. Lovely local walks close to the location.

  Reviewed by Andy5.0★Oct 2023

• "A real jewel in the crown - Tracey and Glenn have taken holiday let's to the next level."

  Cosy and welcoming from the moment of arrival. Already checking out diaries to see when we can return.

  Reviewed by Judy5.0★Oct 2023

• "What a lovely cottage in a beautiful location."

  The village of hope is ideal for everything there is a spar shop a great bakers and a wonderful farm shop ,all within a minute walk.There are many lovely walks from the door loose hill to mam tor was my favourite. The cottage was very clean with everything you needed,with a lovely log burner,the pub next door had great beers and good food. Excellent!!

  Reviewed by Martin5.0★Oct 2023

• "Lovely cottage, would recommend :)"

  Reviewed by Danni5.0★Aug 2023

• "The cottage was beautiful but we were extremely disappointed and shocked to find that the Hope beer festival (which the owners confirmed they knew about) was going on outside the front door in a fixed venue open air marque for the entire four days of our stay."

  Whilst the listing refers to the fact that the property is next door to a pub it does not mention the fixed marque located in the pub car park only a few feet from the property front door. We checked the pub website and the visitor book and it is clear that the marquee hosts live music events on an ongoing regular basis and has done for at least the last six months if not longer. It was clear from the visitor book that guests staying at the property previously have also complained about this issue but the owner has chosen to disregard these complaints and not let people staying know or mention it in the listing. We are not complainers and have no issue being located next to a pub, or with occasional noise. However this was four days and four nights of live music, playing at a volume that meant we couldn’t hear the TV. We think it’s important that future visitors to the cottage are informed either at the time or in advance of them booking and it should also be mentioned in the listing that the marque (not the pub itself) is situated right outside the house and that the pub hosts live music event in it. We consider it to be a dereliction of duty for any cottage owner and renting agent who are aware of the existence of the marque and live events not to mention it to prospective renters and we are extremely unhappy that it was not mentioned to us at the time we made our booking (despite the owner being aware). Unfortunately the level and extent of the noise of the live bands meant that we had to go out for the entire four days meaning we could not enjoy the cottage as we had hoped.

  Thank you for your feedback unfortunately they are many untruths to your feedback. The margue is not a fixed venue and is only there such as beer festivals on some bank holiday weekends. We have had no previous complaints, feedback have been positive stating that they enjoyed the vibe and the buzz. Regarding the noise levels it's a country pub in a rural location with a cow farm 70 yards from the pub. We have never received complaints regarding noise levels. Disappointed that you choose to complain on a Sunday evening your last night 15 minutes before midnight when you was vacating the next morning. Your stay was over a bank holiday weekend which obviously is going to be busier than a normal weekend. The weekend in question we did not know any event was scheduled as you claim. Property Owner

  Reviewed by Jaye3.4★Aug 2023

• "Lovely cottage very comfortable everything need would recommend it to friends"

  Reviewed by Sandra4.7★Aug 2023

• "This is my second stay at the cottage and I will certainly be returning again."

  The Old Hall Barn is a lovely, clean and comfortable cottage with all that you need. It is also in an excellent location, close to all amenities.

  Reviewed by Kathyann5.0★Jul 2023

• "We really enjoyed our stay."

  The accommodation was perfect. Everything you could wish for and spotlessly clean.

  Reviewed by Maria5.0★Jun 2023

• "Comfortable, clean and full of character"

  Reviewed by Sarah5.0★Jun 2023

• "Lovely barn really nice place to be few areas ready for a refresh but they are ..."

  Lovely barn really nice place to be few areas ready for a refresh but they are tiny everything else location the layout can not be faulted lovely touch of having milk in the fridge and some cookies was a really nice touch well equipped kitchen would/will definitely stay again

  Reviewed by Mark4.7★May 2023

• "Property as described and very nicely accessorised, very clean, warm and comfy."

  Owners extremely helpful. A super location especially out of season whilst the village is quieter. Good choice of shops and eateries and all the people we met were very welcoming and friendly (adjourning pub and tea-room very good). Fantastic walks from the door. Beautiful Castleton just a short walk away. I would suggest as one of the other people mentioned. That the property is overdue a little TLC. A re-paint here and there and a few other things need attention as all homes require after time, however, this would not prevent me from re-booking this property again in the future.

  Reviewed by Mandy4.7★Jan 2023

• "My children and I had a fantastic, comfortable stay in The Old Hall Barn."

  The cottage had everything we needed, was warm and comfortable and was in the perfect location. The Christmas decorations were a lovely welcome as were the cakes, tea and coffee. We will definitely be returning.

  Reviewed by Kathyann5.0★Dec 2022

• "We had a lovely time at Old Hall Barn."

  A lovely property in a great location with the added bonus of off road parking. Just a couple of little things - the bathroom now needs a little bit of TLC, ie. there was no toilet seat lid & in general needs a bit of attention. The floor covering in the kitchen didn't seem to fit properly. However, these were minor issues & we really enjoyed our stay, Thank you.

  Reviewed by Kim4.1★Oct 2022

• "Perfect place to stay & location for our stay in the Peak District."

  Reviewed by Jennifer5.0★Aug 2022

• "A lovely cottage in a converted barn right in the heart of Hope."

  For those who enjoy all the facilities of a lovely Peak District village (Lively pub, local shop, Church etc) this couldn't have been a better place. The cottage is bordered on 2 sides by the beer garden of the pub next door, and so for those who want to enjoy a meal and drink out, this cottage is perfectly situated, but guests must be prepared for noise, especially in the mornings when many deliveries are being made. Having said all this, we had a lovely stay and made the most of being so close to facilities.

  Reviewed by Catrin4.4★Aug 2022

• "Could not have asked for a better place."

  Reviewed by Julie5.0★Aug 2022

• "Lovely well equipped cottage in good location for exploring the Peaks and Dales."

  Could not fault it.

  Reviewed by Julie4.7★Jun 2022

• "Great cottage with everything we needed, comfortable for 3 or at a push 4 people."

  Spacious off street parking and the welcome pack (fresh milk and cake!) was a nice touch. Excellent location for heading off into the Peak District, most well known routes are only a short drive away, or you can walk directly from Hope. Decent pub next door as well, what more could you ask for!

  Reviewed by Guy4.4★Apr 2022

• "A lovely, comfortable and well provided for property with some great views."

  Good location for walks, recommend the footpath between Hope and Castleton, better than the road, albeit a bit longer than main road but good for dogs.

  Reviewed by Andy5.0★Mar 2022

• "Great cottage in perfect location, 2nd time weve been and would return, pubs ,shops and walks straight out the door"

  Reviewed by Adam5.0★Feb 2022

• "Having used Sykes cottage on numerous occasions all have been relatively OK with the description some being economical with the actual cottage and with photos giving a more appealing view Not with the old barn it was exactly what it described excellent in every way clean warn comfortable great shower all you need for a week away hiking etc great area 2 local pubs only a short bus ride to Castleton with over 6 pubs."

  We lost the doors key Tracey and Husband didn’t have a problem with the drive from home to drop of a replacement key offered to pay but said no problem enjoy the rest of the holiday Will certainly book again and recommend to friends

  Reviewed by Phil5.0★Dec 2021

• "A lovely property in a wonderful location."

  Very clean & well equipped. We really enjoyed our stay & will be booking again next year.

  Reviewed by Kim5.0★Dec 2021

• "Absolutely 5*!"

  Spotlessly clean and so very thoughtful in every way. Many little details that were really appreciated from flashlights to complimentary items. So comfortable and stylish too. We really felt made welcome and thoroughly enjoyed our stay.! Location is fabulous, shop, café and pub within a minute walk. The perfect place in every way.

  Reviewed by Andrea5.0★Nov 2021

• "Everything in the cottage was as stated on the website."

  It was very comfortable, warm and cosy. The kitchen is well equipped and we appreciated the milk and cookies left for us. We heard no noise from the pub next door but did enjoy it for a meal and drinks. Excellent location for visiting all the sites and attractions in the north of the Peak District. There was nothing to fault with the cottage and the owners were quick to respond to a query I made before visiting. Would thoroughly recommend.

  Reviewed by Simon5.0★Nov 2021

• "We had a lovely break (postponed from 2020) with our now one year old - the cottage suited us with a toddler just as well as it would have with a newborn though."

  Plenty to do in the outdoors nearby - we enjoyed climbing Lose Hill, cycling the Monsal way and a trip to Peak Wildlife Park. Would recommend - but would suggest bringing your own potato peeler!

  Reviewed by Susannah5.0★Apr 2021

• "We have enjoyed a week in this comfortable and well equipped cottage ( barn)."

  Good location for visiting the Peak District and walking in the area.

  Reviewed by Barry4.4★Oct 2020

• "Old Hall Barn is a comfortable, clean and cosy cottage."

  Located in a good area for walking with walks straight out of the door. The pub next door serves good food and isn't noisy.

  Reviewed by Jane5.0★Aug 2020

• "A very hot week in a very hot barn."

  Parking is limited on the streets so having a parking space was essential. The garden is enclosed and safe for young families although the photo is old and suggests otherwise. Recycling information would be handy, along with the option of putting the bins out. This is something we do at home and feel that we should comply elsewhere. Old hall barn is such a lovely place to stay and visit the hope valley. Walks are from the doorstep and pubs are in plentiful supply - so no cooking required!

  Reviewed by Tammy4.7★Aug 2020

• "This cottage is charming and cosy, in a fantastic location."

  Hope is a bustling village with a good selection of cafes! The pub literally next door is very handy but not too noisy. It has spaced out tables outside for social distancing and staff all wearing visors. The hot water went during our stay but the owners got it fixed very quickly so it was no problem. We had a lovely stay but would recommend a bigger outdoor bin, as a family of 4 self catering a lot we had a lot of nappies and rubbish every day! Also bring some toilet rolls with you as 2 not enough for a week. The garden is safe and secure, ideal for kids and the view of the peaks is lovely and peaceful. We enjoyed hearing the cows on the field next door, luckily we were already up at 5am with the baby as they’re pretty loud!! If you have a baby, bring your own cot and high chair. There’s loads to do for families close by, in addition to all the hiking, including Hathersage outdoor pool (prebook), Thorpe farm (Hope valley ice cream where you can see cows being milked by a machine) and in Matlock the Heights of Abraham and Gullivers kingdom are super fun. Don’t forget your masks!

  Reviewed by Georgie4.7★Jul 2020

• "We had a lovely 3 night stay at old hall barn."

  The cottage had everything we needed, was very clean and in the perfect location with 2 pubs close by, and a spar to buy any loving we might have needed. Loved how close it was to Castleton, we got a bus in so we could enjoy a few drinks which only took a couple of minutes. Would recommend to anyone staying here, as we will most likely be booking again.

  Reviewed by Claire5.0★Feb 2020

• "Fabulous cottage very warm with excellent central heating (cost included) finished to a very high standard, overall delighted with every aspect of the accommodation."

  Located next to a pub was actually very helpful, hardly new it was there and never any problem with noise. Difficult to obtain logs for fire. Also toilet should have a proper lock . But overall excellent value for money.

  Reviewed by Leslie5.0★Nov 2019

• "A great place to stay - very well located with pubs, shops and cafes very close by and not far from the station."

  The cottage itself was nice and warm and well equipped, including a DVD player which was a nice bonus. We're already making plans for a repeat visit.

  Reviewed by John5.0★Nov 2019

• "Cottage very clean, no problems, even though very near to pub and tea rooms, no noise at all."

  Good location for walking, cycling, most enjoyable holiday, apart from the weather. Reasonable priced and good food in tea room during day, pub in the evening. Everything you needed was provided. Private parking was a bonus.

  Reviewed by Alexander5.0★Sep 2019

• "Nice place."

  Good pub next door, plus views of Hope Church opposite. Lovely walks. Overall very satisfied. Suggestions to owner: Upstairs bedroom needs ventilation at the apex as it has no window of its own. Also fewer ornaments/niknaks would reduce clutter and free up surfaces. Many thanks. Nick

  Reviewed by Nick4.4★Sep 2019

• "It is a really fantastic location - comprising of all you need and want after a wonderful walk through the nearby hills."

  Makes you feel at home immediately! Thanks to great hosts and th lovely interior.

  Reviewed by Annette5.0★Aug 2019

• "Good base for exploring the Peak District."

  The barn is in a village, was very clean, and well equipped

  Reviewed by Colin4.7★Aug 2019

• "Cottage great position."

  Well fitted out

  Reviewed by Isabel5.0★Jul 2019

• "Steps to bedroom steep"

  Reviewed by Joyce5.0★Jun 2019

• "The cottage was lovely well equipped and homely."

  Well done to Tracey.

  Reviewed by Andrew5.0★Apr 2019

• "A lovely stay at old hall barn, great location to explore the area."

  Thanks

  Reviewed by Lee5.0★Mar 2019

• "Great cottage , great location next to pub and cafe - great food at affordable ..."

  Great cottage , great location next to pub and cafe - great food at affordable prices Lovely local walks and drive to Buxton for shops 20 mins away Would strongly recommend

  Reviewed by Donna5.0★Feb 2019

• "The barn was very much as advertised, and, importantly for a very cold weekend, the central heating worked most effectively and was straightforward to control."

  The fridge freezer was also a good size. The only negative was the level of clutter. Every surface and most cupboards were full - it was really difficult to find space for our things. A self catering cottage should leave plenty of room in the kitchen for provisions, and plenty of work surface free for preparation. Similarly, the sitting room should have space for our clutter - we had to move lots of ornaments (some floor standing and heavy), old magazines, and even unnecessary seats, in order to find space for us to spread out. That said, the location was perfect, the seats and beds were comfortable, and we thoroughly enjoyed our stay

  Reviewed by Mary4.4★Jan 2019

• "Lovely place to stay for a greatwinter getaway, the barn was Christmas decorated which was a lovely touch, very comfortable and cosy and the owner was easy to contact when needed!"

  the village was a lovely welcoming place with amazing scenery

  Reviewed by Zoe4.7★Dec 2018

• "The thing we most enjoyed besides the super cottage was when we went into ..."

  The thing we most enjoyed besides the super cottage was when we went into Castleton it was so warm and friendly and very Christmassy which at night looked amazing we did not want to come home on Sunday but had to

  Reviewed by Julie5.0★Nov 2018

• "Very warm and comfortable place to stay."

  Well equipped cottage. Great location for starting your walks in the Peak District. Smaller supermarket nearby. Great food at The Old Hall Hotel (pub and tearoom), and at the Curry Cabin.

  Reviewed by C.j.5.0★Oct 2018

• "Excellent base to explore the Peak District with plenty of amenities and excellent pubs within walking distance."

  Downstairs bedroom is a double but it is a very cosy double (more like 3/4 bed) but don't let this deter. It is an excellent property and highly recommend particularly for couples and/or small family.

  Reviewed by Rachael4.7★Oct 2018

• "Every afternoon a bar at the nearby terrace."

  Great location.

  Reviewed by Corrie4.7★Jun 2018

• "Gorgeous property, wasn’t expecting it to be so luxurious and yet still homely and cosy!"

  Everything was clean and tidy, the milk in the fridge was a lovely addition. Great location, would definitely recommend.

  Reviewed by Mary5.0★Jun 2018

• "Excellent holiday cottage in a prime location, it’s near a pub/hotel but didn’t bother us in the slightest all week."

  The TV was massive for a property like this, the facilities were top notch and everything we needed was there.

  Reviewed by Sally5.0★Jun 2018

• There are no reviews featuring this term Show all reviews